I came from a 2 seat General Trailhead Edition to the XP5 Northstar. I will be honest; I do miss the nimbleness of my 2 seater, but to have the extra space in the 5 seater (let's be honest, really 4 seater) is nice, especially when we have a plus 1 or 2 that want to come along. It all boils down to what you need. I also went from a JL Jeep to a JT Gladiator and can now tow 7K, which is great for me. Maybe do an upgrade from your JK to a JT? If you're into the Jeep thing like I am, it's a good choice....and the JTs are deeply discounted now....decisions, decisions.....lol.